Quote:
Originally Posted by Patmuscled! I absolutely agree. It's a common bodybuilding saying that if you want to grow, you have to become stronger first. That stronger muscles means bigger muscles. It makes sense, however, it also makes as much sense to believe that bigger muscles means stronger muscles. The thing is that we've seen some relatively skinny guys who are as strong, if not stronger, as those guys who outweigh them by forty or fifty pounds. And there are guys who can get constantly bigger without gaining noticeable strength.
The logic behind the notion that stronger muscles means bigger muscles is the fact that if you lift heavier as you gain strength, the more stress you give your muscles and more stress means more growth stimulus. But can our muscles tell the difference between a 250-pound and a 50-pound barbell? If I can bench press fifty pounds for a maximum of eight reps today, and then bench press 250 pounds for a maximum of eight reps six years after, would my muscles know that I'm lifting 200 pounds more now than six years ago? No. |
There are many factors that contribute to a persons functional strength apart from muscle size, such as bone structure, muscle insertion points, muscle fibers per motor unit etc. Hence why there are people exceptionally strong for their size.
These factors however are predetermined and will not change no matter what you do with training/nutrition. The only thing you can change is your muscle size. Granted it is not a direct correlation, as muscle can increase in efficiency as well, but a correlation nonetheless.
You can find small guys who are strong, as explained in my first paragraph, but you will never EVER find a big guy who is weak. Period.
As for you last statement:
"If I can bench press fifty pounds for a maximum of eight reps today, and then bench press 250 pounds for a maximum of eight reps six years after, would my muscles know that I'm lifting 200 pounds more now than six years ago? No."
I don't want to start an argument here, perhaps I'm misunderstanding the post....
Are you suggesting that increasing your bench by 200lbs for 8 reps would go unnoticed by your muscles?
Please elaborate.....