i think jay would do alot better if he dropped 10-15 lbs, ronnie wins because he's got sharper definition with the his mass. jay has good mass, hecan keep up with ronnie but in my opinion he comes to these competitions looking a bit soft which is why he places 2nd. you can see some differences in his biceps and his chest, compared to ronnie. jay had some wide lats, in some pictures they looked wider than ronnie's but ronnie had more detail.
i think the olympia judging needs some refining. these bodybuilders are all getting super huge and alot compete looking real soft, it's pathetic. i think people like dexter jackson, who have
symmetry and are cut up should be winning, not people who carry alot of weight with just a great look. it should be something extraordinary. and i'm not just pointing at dexter, lee priest seems to be very underrated as well.
i think it was last year when dexter competed with ronnie and jay and placed low. dexter and jay were posing together and i still cant believe jay beat him.
i guess size does matter...but definition and sharpness of the muscles should be key.